CYBER WELFARE

Protect your Digital Privacy

How to manage multiple online identities: the steps in priority order

Online identities multiply without anyone really thinking about it. A profile with your name for friends and family, one for work, a blog under a pseudonym, the account of your residents’ association, a nickname on a forum. Each one was born at a different moment, often with whatever email address and phone you had to hand. After a few years, many of them share more than you would imagine.

Working out how to manage multiple online identities does not take technical skills or special software. It takes a sequence of simple steps, done in the right order, and the habit of checking them again when you open a new account or change phone.

This guide is the practical side of the recommendation to keep separate online identities apart. It follows four phases: prevention, to give each identity its own set; detection, to find the points in common; response, to separate again what has crossed over; recovery, to handle a link that other people already know about. The tools you will find in browsers, phones and email services, with their strengths and limits, are described in the post on digital compartmentalisation.

Before you start: why the order matters

Points in common do not all weigh the same. It makes sense to start with the ones that link identities directly and leave until last the ones that only matter when they add up.

PriorityPoint in commonWhy
1Email address or username containing your nameIt is the direct link, readable by anyone
2Same recovery email or numberIt links the identities for the service and ties their fate together
3Same password, or nearlyIf one is exposed, the other falls and the link is revealed
4Same profile picture, recurring photos, recognisable placesIt is visible to everyone and can be found with an image search
5“Sign in with…” your personal profile, connected appsThe service knows both identities are yours
6Same browser or same app with several accountsShared cookies and sign-ins; wrong-account mistakes are easy
7Contacts, uploaded address book, people you followPeople and service suggestions connect things that look alike
8Times of day, phrases, life details in your postsOn their own they weigh little; together with the others, a lot

A useful note: not every identity needs the same level of separation. A profile for a hobby you talk about with everyone can share something with your personal one. How much to separate depends on what is at stake, and it is the starting question of the recommendation on deciding how much anonymity you need.

1. Prevention: a dedicated set for each identity

Give the identity an address of its own

Create an email address just for the separate identity, without your name in it. An address with an addition, such as “name+blog@”, is handy for filtering mail, but it separates nothing: anyone who sees it also reads the main address. For services you use rarely you can also consider a throwaway address, as the glossary entry on junk email addresses explains.

Give it its own recovery

Recovery for the dedicated address should not go through your personal email. Choose a separate recovery and note it in your password manager, together with the backup codes many services provide. If a service asks for a phone number, ask yourself whether it is really needed: the recommendation on sharing your phone number only where it is needed helps you decide.

Protect the account like all the others

A unique password, generated and stored in your password manager, as the recommendation on using a unique password for every account asks. Two-step verification turned on, ideally with an authenticator app, as the recommendation on protecting accounts with a second factor explains. A separate identity is not a second-class account.

Separate browser and apps

Use a browser profile dedicated to the identity: it has its own cookies, sign-ins and history. On your phone, if an app lets you connect several accounts, consider keeping just one there and using the other in the browser. For the separate identity, do not use “Sign in with…” your personal profile.

Read the service’s rules

Rules on pseudonyms and multiple accounts vary from service to service. Some ask you to use the name you go by in everyday life; others accept pseudonyms, pages or multiple accounts. The EFF notes that so-called “real name” policies have become more relaxed over time on many services, but they have not disappeared. Before opening a separate identity, read the terms: if they do not allow it, choose another service or another format, such as a page or a blog.

2. Detection: finding the points in common

Take stock in two columns

Take a sheet of paper, or a document you keep to yourself, and split it into two columns: the identity with your name and the separate one. Write down, line by line, sign-up email, recovery email and number, password, profile picture, connected apps, browser, people followed in common, posting times. Every line that is the same in both columns is a point in common.

Check each account’s settings

On the account page you will find, under different names depending on the service, the sign-up email, the number, the recovery options, the connected apps and the active sessions, meaning the devices you appear to be signed in on. Go through them one by one: the point in common is often there, forgotten.

Search for your separate identity the way someone else would

Search for the pseudonym on a search engine, from a private window, and look at what comes up alongside it. Do the same with your name. If a result puts them side by side, you have found a visible link. Pay attention to photos too: if an image appears on both identities, it is the easiest link to find.

Reread your latest posts

Pick ten recent posts from the separate identity and look for details of your life: your neighbourhood, your job, your children’s school, an event you attended under your own name. These are links no setting can remove.

3. Response: separating again what has crossed over

Change recovery details in the right order

First add the new address or recovery method and check that it works; only then remove the old one. If you do it the other way round, you risk locking yourself out of your account.

Remove photos and content that lead to you

Remove or archive photos posted on both identities, those taken in recognisable places and those with the location saved, as the recommendation on turning off photo geotagging explains. Replace the profile picture with an image you do not use anywhere else.

Disconnect apps and sessions

Remove “Sign in with…” wherever the separate identity used your personal profile, and sign up again with the dedicated address. Sign out of sessions you do not recognise or no longer need. If you had uploaded your contacts, check whether the service lets you delete them: some allow it from the settings.

Decide what to accept

Not everything needs separating again. If a trusted person has discovered the link, you can simply ask them to keep it to themselves. If a link has become public, separating again protects the future, it does not erase the past: sometimes it makes more sense to accept it and change only what exposes you most.

4. Recovery: if other people already know about the link

Talk to the people who know

A simple, honest message, such as “Yes, it’s me: I’d rather it stayed between us”, almost always works better than a denial. People respect a clear request more readily than silence.

Ask for what exposes you to be removed

If someone has written your name under a post from the separate identity, you can ask them to take it down, or delete the comment if you are able to. If personal information has been spread, such as your home address or workplace, use the platform’s reporting tools; if the platform does not respond, you can complain to the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO).

If someone uses your name or pretends to be you

Gather evidence (screenshots showing the date and the page address), report the profile to the platform and, if there are threats or attempts at fraud, contact the police. If you feel in danger, for example because someone close to you is monitoring or threatening you, the first step is to talk to a specialist service: in England, GOV.UK lists Refuge’s National Domestic Abuse Helpline, free and open 24 hours a day.

If you decide to start again

You can close an identity and open another, this time starting from a dedicated set. Do it within the service’s rules: starting again to protect your privacy is legitimate; opening a new account to get round a suspension or a ban is not.

A plan in three sessions

There is no need to do everything at once. Three short sessions are enough.

SessionWhenWhat to doTime
1TodayTake stock, in two columns, of your most important separate identity15 minutes
2Within a weekGive the identity its own address, recovery and password; open a dedicated browser profile; remove “Sign in with…”30 minutes
3Within a monthReview photos, contacts and recent posts; put a reminder in your diary to check whenever you open a new account or change phone20 minutes

Common mistakes when putting things right

  • Removing the old recovery before checking the new one. It is the quickest way to get locked out.
  • Deleting the account in a panic. You lose the content and, often, the link has already been seen. Better to wait a day and decide calmly.
  • Starting again with the same points in common. A new pseudonym with the same photo or the same number gets linked quickly.
  • Denying it to people who already know. A denial that does not hold up draws more attention than a request for discretion.
  • Separating only your phone. The laptop, the family tablet and connected apps often keep the old sign-ins.

Action checklist

Prevention

  • ☐ The separate identity has an email address without my name and its own recovery
  • ☐ It has a unique password and two-step verification
  • ☐ It has a dedicated browser profile and does not use “Sign in with…” my personal profile

Detection

  • ☐ I have taken stock of the points in common in two columns
  • ☐ I have checked the email address, number, connected apps and active sessions of each account

Response

  • ☐ I have changed recovery details by adding the new one first and removing the old one afterwards
  • ☐ I have removed the photos and content that linked the two identities

Recovery

  • ☐ I know how to ask for discretion from someone who has discovered the link
  • ☐ I know who to turn to if someone spreads my information or uses my name

Mini-scenario

Lucy, who signs her recipe blog as “Basil”, has already given the blog its own address and browser profile. A few months later, a cousin leaves a comment under a recipe: “Lucy, is this the cake from lunch at Gran’s? Delicious!”. The comment is public, and the name is her real one.

Lucy does not panic. First she messages her cousin privately: “Yes, it’s me! Could you do me a favour? I’d rather people didn’t know the blog is mine”. Her cousin apologises and deletes the comment. Then Lucy opens her list of identities and looks for where the link came from: the cake photo had also been posted in the family group chat, on the evening of the lunch, with the same checked tablecloth.

Lucy decides that she will no longer post those recipes in the days after a family lunch, and that she will always take blog photos on the chopping board, never on the kitchen table. She also checks the family tablet, where her husband had used the blog’s browser profile to look up a recipe: she creates a separate profile for him.

A week later, she goes through the checklist again: every box is ticked. The blog has a few more readers among her relatives, who know and say nothing. For Lucy, that is fine.

How this connects to the Cyber Welfare Framework

PillarHow this content contributes
SkillsKnowing how to take stock of the points in common, change recovery details in the right order and separate browsers, apps and photos
AwarenessUnderstanding that points in common do not all weigh the same and that the priority order makes separation more effective
Secure BehaviourGiving each new identity its own set and knowing what to do when two identities have already crossed over

Reference level: FL3 — Autonomous. This is the level where separation is no longer an occasional fix but a routine that comes with every new identity and includes the response when something goes wrong. To measure your other digital habits, you can take the digital resilience self-assessment.

Conclusion

Managing multiple online identities is more a matter of order than of technology. First the direct links, such as an email address with your name and shared recovery, then the password, photos and connected apps, and finally habits and details in your posts.

The result is a set of identities you know, each with its own set, and the freedom to decide, every time, who knows what.

Related content

Related resources

Short reads from the Resources section, for anyone who wants to focus on a single aspect:

Start with the first step: the Cyber Welfare Programme guides you free of charge, one recommendation at a time.