CYBER WELFARE

Protect your Digital Privacy

Deciding how much anonymity you need: a short personal threat model before the tools

Sarah is twenty-eight, lives in Rome and teaches at a secondary school. One evening, within the space of an hour, three things land in her inbox. The head teacher sends all staff an “anonymous” survey on the school’s working climate. The online group for the tenants in her block is discussing the service charge increase demanded by the letting agency. And the dog rescue centre where she volunteers on Saturdays asks if she would appear, with her name and photo, on its volunteers page.

An article on online privacy lists fifteen tools, each more complicated than the last. Should she install them all? But does she really need the same protection for a staff survey, a tenants’ group and a dog rescue page?

This recommendation, R41 of the Cyber Welfare Framework, invites you to do what Sarah did that evening: decide how much anonymity you need, one situation at a time, before you choose any tool. All it takes is a sheet of paper, five questions and about twenty minutes. The result is not “as much anonymity as possible”, but the right amount for what matters to you, no more and no less.

What this recommendation says

Recommendation R41 states that before choosing an anonymity tool, you write down, for the situations you care about, what you want to protect, from whom, and what would happen if the link came out, and you choose only the protections that match that answer.

A few terms to clear up straight away:

  • a threat model is the set of your answers to a few questions about your situation: what you want to protect, from whom, how likely a problem is, how bad it would be, and how much effort you are willing to put in. The glossary entry on threat models explains it in more depth;
  • anonymity means acting without what you do being traceable, by any reasonable means, back to who you are;
  • a pseudonym is a name other than your own that you use in a particular setting. As the glossary entry on pseudonyms explains, it protects your name, but not always the link;
  • privacy, here, means deciding who sees what, even when you act under your own name.

A pseudonym is not anonymity. It is the most useful distinction here. Recital 26 of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) explains that data separated from a name is still data about an identifiable person if it can be attributed to them using additional information; the ICO, the UK’s data protection regulator, says the same in its guidance: pseudonymised data is still personal data. The same logic applies to an account with a made-up name: if a phone number, a photo, a time of day or a way of writing leads back to you, the link is still there.

In practice, there are three levels, to choose case by case:

  • privacy: you act under your own name, but you decide the audience and the details;
  • pseudonym: you use another name, knowing that a link back to you remains possible;
  • anonymity: you make sure that no reasonable detail leads back to you, and accept more effort.

What it is not. It is not a call to become anonymous everywhere, nor a list of tools. It is not about account security, which remains the foundation of everything, starting with the rule of using a unique password for every account. Nor is it about who can see your social media profile, which is the subject of the recommendation on checking who can see your profile. How to genuinely keep two identities apart is explained in the recommendation on keeping separate identities separate; when you need a browser designed for anonymity, in the recommendation on when to use Tor Browser. And it is not designed for people facing serious, targeted risks, such as journalists, activists or people in danger: they are better served by specialist organisations and, where the risk comes from someone close, by a helpline such as Refuge’s National Domestic Abuse Helpline, listed on GOV.UK (0808 2000 247, free, 24 hours a day).

Where it applies. To situations in which a link with your name worries you, even slightly: an opinion, a group, a search, a profile, a survey. It is about everyday life, not film plots.

Why it matters

Without a plan, advice on anonymity looks like an endless list. With a plan, you can see the few steps that cover what matters to you.

The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), a US digital rights organisation, builds its digital self-defence guide this way: a personal security plan that starts with “what do I want to protect?” and “who do I want to protect it from?”, and only then turns to tools. The same guide warns that there is no perfect option for security, and that your plan can change as your situation changes.

The reason is simple: every step towards anonymity has a cost. A second email address has to be remembered. A browser that hides your network address is slower, and some sites will not work. Pay these costs where they are not needed, and you get tired, make mistakes and give up even where they mattered.

There is also the opposite risk: underestimating how little it takes to recognise you. A study of 1990 US census data estimated that postcode, sex and date of birth were enough to single out 87% of the population. The resource on why a few details can identify you explains the mechanism. An “anonymous” person in a group of ten, with a couple of details, is often not really anonymous.

Finally, anonymity is a freedom with limits. A 2015 report by the UN Special Rapporteur on freedom of expression concluded that encryption and anonymity deserve strong protection. In a judgment of 7 December 2021, the European Court of Human Rights also stressed the value of online anonymity, while making clear that it is not an absolute right. Deciding how much anonymity you need is not about escaping the rules, but about protecting what you are entitled to protect.

The practical effects show up in four areas:

  • disproportionate tools: time, effort and broken websites, to protect something that did not need it;
  • insufficient protection: a pseudonym believed to be anonymous, which breaks at the first detail;
  • mistakes from fatigue: too many rules at once, and sooner or later one gets skipped;
  • choices driven by fear: not taking part, instead of deciding how to take part.
Benefit of deciding how much anonymity you needWhy it matters
You know what you are protecting, and from whomProtection goes where it counts
You choose the right level for each situationPrivacy, pseudonym or anonymity, without mixing them up
You avoid tools you do not needLess effort, fewer mistakes, more consistency
You recognise the limits of a pseudonymNo false sense of security
You redo the sheet when life changesThe plan stays yours, and up to date

A concrete example

Sarah takes a sheet of paper and divides it into three rows, one per situation. For each one she writes five short answers.

The staff survey. What is she protecting? The link between her criticisms and her name. From whom? The school’s leadership. Likelihood: medium, because her department has nine teachers and the survey asks for subject, years of service and age band. Impact: medium, tension at work she would rather avoid. Effort: low. No tool will fix this: with three details, the group she blends into shrinks to one or two people. She leaves the optional questions on years of service and age band blank, and writes comments without recognisable incidents. For one specific criticism she decides to speak up in person, under her own name. Level chosen: anonymity, as far as the setting allows.

The tenants’ group. She is protecting the link between her opinions on the agency and her name, because her tenancy ends next year. From whom? The agency. Likelihood: low. Impact: medium. Effort: a few minutes. She uses a made-up name and a photo without her face, and does not mention her flat number. She knows her neighbours will recognise her anyway, and she is fine with that. Level: pseudonym.

The rescue centre page. Nothing to hide here: Sarah is happy to be recognised. She just asks them to use her first name only and not mention where she lives. Level: privacy.

No new tools. At the bottom of the sheet there is a reminder: reread it if she changes school or moves house.

When to apply it

There are moments when the sheet makes an obvious difference.

  • When something makes you uneasy. An opinion, a group, a search: unease is the sign that two lines on paper are worth writing.
  • Before installing an anonymity tool. Ask yourself which row of your sheet it covers.
  • When you are promised anonymity. Surveys, reports, polls: ask how big the group you blend into is, and which details you are being asked for.
  • When you open an account under a made-up name. Decide then what must not link it to you: email, number, photos, contacts.
  • When your life changes. A new job, a move, a break-up, a more public role: yesterday’s answers may no longer hold.

How to apply it

No expertise needed, just a short sequence to repeat.

  1. Choose two or three situations. An account, something you share, something you look up. Use short labels, never real secrets or passwords.
  2. Ask yourself what you want to protect. Often it is not a secret but a link: your name with an opinion, your private life with your work.
  3. Name the audience. Who are you protecting it from? A colleague, an ex, a neighbour, an advertiser, a stranger searching for your name. Rarely is it a skilled adversary.
  4. Weigh likelihood and impact. How likely is it that someone reaches the link, and how much would it matter to you? Low, medium or high is enough.
  5. Decide how much effort you will accept. A few minutes, an evening or a new habit. If the effort exceeds what you are willing to give, choose a lighter level or a different way of taking part.
  6. Choose the level and the lightest step that covers it. Privacy, pseudonym or anonymity. Often the step is simple: a more closed profile, a separate email address, a sign-in that does not go through your social media account, as the recommendation on limiting social login suggests.
  7. Set a date to reread the sheet. Six months, or the next big change. In the meantime, look at what the services you use already know about you, as explained in the recommendation on reviewing what your accounts keep about you.

The steps for putting the sheet into practice, from prevention to recovery, are in the guide on how to protect your anonymity online. What each technology protects, and what it does not, is explained in the post on anonymity technologies.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Starting from the tool. A strong tool used for the wrong situation costs effort and does not protect what matters. The sheet first, then the tool.
  • Believing a pseudonym is anonymity. A made-up name with your phone number, your photo or your routine can still be traced back to you.
  • Trusting the word “anonymous”. A survey in a small group, with questions on age and role, can identify you without anyone meaning to.
  • Putting your whole life on the highest level. It is tiring and leads to mistakes. Proportion protects better than maximum protection.
  • Writing the sheet once and forgetting it. The plan is a snapshot: when your situation changes, it needs redoing.

How this connects to the Cyber Welfare Framework

R41 comes before the tools. It puts the others in order: it tells you when controlling a profile’s audience is enough, when to keep two identities apart and when a browser designed for anonymity is worth the trouble.

PillarHow this contributes
SkillsKnowing how to answer the five questions, roughly weigh likelihood and impact, and tell privacy, pseudonym and anonymity apart
AwarenessUnderstanding that the need for anonymity varies from person to person and from one situation to another, and that every step has a cost
Secure BehaviourChoosing the lightest step that covers each situation and rereading the sheet when life changes

Digital maturity levels.

  • FL1 — Basic. You follow scattered advice, or none, without knowing what you are protecting. It is the most common starting point, not a fault.
  • FL2 — Beginner. You have written your sheet for two or three situations and can tell a pseudonym from anonymity.
  • FL3 — Autonomous. You choose the level for each new situation, keep apart the settings that matter and reread the sheet whenever something changes.
  • FL4 — Skilled. You spot when an “anonymous” setting will not hold, estimate the group you blend into and fix links before they become a problem.
  • FL5 — Expert-Guide. You help family, colleagues or students write their own sheet, calmly and without frightening them.

R41 is the key step towards FL2, and it remains the starting point at every level after that.

How to check you are applying it properly

Three questions, to be answered honestly.

  • For the situations I care about, could I say what I am protecting and from whom?
  • Am I using tools I could not match to any particular situation?
  • Is there an account under a made-up name that I think of as anonymous, but that could lead back to me?

Quick checklist

  • ☐ I have written the sheet for at least two situations
  • ☐ For each one I know what I am protecting, from whom and how bad it would be
  • ☐ I have chosen a level: privacy, pseudonym or anonymity
  • ☐ I know what could link my pseudonyms to me
  • ☐ I have dropped or avoided tools that serve no row on the sheet
  • ☐ I have set a date to reread the sheet

If a box stays empty, you already have your next step. For a more structured measure of your level, take the digital resilience self-assessment.

In short

Not every situation needs the same protection. A personal threat model, five answers on a sheet of paper, tells you what to protect, from whom and with how much effort, and so which level to choose: privacy, pseudonym or anonymity.

The rule is proportion: the lightest step that covers what matters, remembering that a pseudonym is not anonymity and that “anonymous” in a small group does not mean much. The sheet is reread when life changes.

The tools come afterwards. You come first, with what matters to you.

Something to think about. If you had to pick just one part of your online life to keep apart from your name, which would it be, and from whom?

Explore this recommendation

This recommendation is the pivot of a content unit. Each post looks at a different aspect.

Related resources

Short reads from the Resources section, for anyone who wants to focus on a single aspect:

Start with the first step: the Cyber Welfare Programme guides you free of charge, one recommendation at a time.