CYBER WELFARE

Protect your Digital Privacy

Signs your identities are crossing over: how to notice and what they mean

Two separate identities cross over quietly. No notification tells you that your pseudonym and your name have just shared a detail. You find out afterwards: an odd suggestion, a comment with your real name, an email that lands in the wrong inbox. For most people these are harmless episodes. But they are also the simplest way to find out whether the separation you thought you had really holds.

This post gathers the signs your identities are crossing over: some you will find in your account settings, others you will notice while using services and talking to people. None of these signs, on its own, means the link is known to everyone. Together, they tell you whether it is time to put things back in order.

It is the diagnostic side of the recommendation to keep separate online identities apart. The ways two separate identities get linked back together, by people watching them or by services, are explained in the post on identity correlation attacks.

What these signs are

In cyber security people talk about indicators: traces suggesting that a situation deserves attention. For separate identities, indicators come in two kinds:

  • technical, meaning information you find in the settings: the recovery email and number, connected apps, active sessions, notifications;
  • observable, meaning behaviour you notice while using services or talking to people: a suggestion, a comment, a question.

An indicator is not proof. It is an invitation to look more closely.

Why they matter more as an identity grows

A newly opened identity, with few posts and few contacts, has few points in common with the others. An identity you have used for years builds up photos, posts, followers, connected apps, sign-ins from several devices. The more material there is, the more likely it is that some detail matches the identity that carries your name, and that someone notices.

The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) guide to social networks points out that friends can unintentionally identify you, report your location and make their connections to you public. That is why many signs do not come from the settings, but from people. And services add their own: to suggest profiles to follow, they can use clues such as mutual contacts or, depending on the service, address books uploaded by users. Exactly how they do it is not public, and it changes over time: that is why it is better to watch for the signs than to try to guess the mechanism.

Technical indicators

IndicatorWhere you see itWhat it may meanHow much it weighsWhat to do
The separate identity’s recovery goes through your personal emailAccount settings › security or recoveryThe two identities are linked for the service and share the same weak pointHighGive the identity its own recovery
The separate identity’s notifications arrive in your personal inboxInboxThe sign-up or recovery email is the wrong oneHighChange the address, adding the new one first
The same phone number on both identitiesAccount settingsServices can use the number to connect peopleHighConsider another method, or a different number
The separate identity uses “Sign in with…” your personal profileConnected apps, in your personal profile’s settingsThe service knows both identities are yoursMedium-highDisconnect it and sign up with the dedicated address
Active sessions on shared devicesSessions or connected devicesOthers can see or use the identity from the same deviceMediumSign out of sessions you do not need
Contacts uploaded or synced from the separate identityContact settingsThe service can suggest the identity to people who know youMediumTurn off syncing and, if possible, delete the uploaded contacts

Signs you can spot yourself

SignWhen you notice itWhat it may meanHow much it weighsWhat to do
The separate identity is suggested to people you knowSomeone tells you, or you see itA number, an address book or mutual contacts link the identitiesMedium-highFind the point in common and change it
The separate identity suggests people from your named lifeIn the suggestions sectionThe service has found a link between you and themMediumCheck number, contacts and connected apps
Someone writes your real name under a post from the separate identityIn the commentsAt least one person already knows the linkHighAsk for discretion; remove the comment if you can
Someone uses your name under your pseudonym, or pretends to be youComments, messages, new profilesThe link is known and is being used against youHighGather evidence and report it to the platform
The same little-known people follow both identitiesFollower listSomeone has linked them, or services suggest them togetherMediumReview who can see the separate identity
One of your photos appears somewhere you did not post itIn a search, or someone tells youThe image links identities or has been copiedMedium-highRemove shared photos; report copies
You posted from the wrong accountAfter a comment or a likeThe identities live in the same spaceMediumSeparate browser and apps

Signs on shared devices and spaces

Your phone is not the only place where identities cross over. Often it is the laptop, or the family tablet, that holds them together. Some signs are typical of these spaces:

  • the browser offers the separate identity’s email address while you sign in to your personal one: the two identities use the same browser profile and the same store of saved data;
  • a family member asks whose profile is signed in on the tablet: the separate identity has been left open on a device other people use;
  • your work computer is signed in to the separate identity: whoever manages that computer may see its activity, and the identity mixes with your professional one;
  • your password manager shows both identities on the same screen while someone is looking: not a technical risk, but a link visible to whoever is next to you.

In all these cases the check is the same: ask yourself, for each device, which identities should be on it and with which profile.

A concrete example

Sarah is in her late twenties and, under the pseudonym “Otter”, posts comic strips about commuter life. Nobody at work knows, and she likes it that way.

One Friday a colleague shows her his phone during a break: “Look, it’s suggesting this Otter. Their strips about the 7.42 train look just like our train!”. Sarah smiles and changes the subject. That evening she opens Otter’s account settings. The phone number linked to it is her own, the one her colleague has in his contacts. And the recovery email is her personal inbox: that is why notifications about new followers arrive there, mixed in with the gym’s emails.

Then she looks at the past month’s strips. In one she has carefully drawn the station café, with its recognisable sign. In another there is a colleague with a detail anyone who knows her would spot straight away.

Nothing has happened. But the signs were there: a suggestion to someone who knows her, recovery in the wrong inbox, life details in the drawings.

That evening Sarah creates an address just for Otter, adds it as the recovery address and, once it is verified, removes her personal one. She replaces the number with an authenticator app for two-step verification. She decides that, from now on, the station café will be any café.

What to check straight away

If one of the signs in the tables sounds familiar, these are the first checks to make, in this order:

  1. Where does the separate identity’s recovery go? Email and number: if they match those of the identity with your name, they are the first thing to change.
  2. Does the separate identity use “Sign in with…” your personal profile? Check the connected apps on both.
  3. Are your contacts uploaded or synced? Look at the contact settings.
  4. Which devices appear as signed in? Sign out of sessions you do not need.
  5. Do the profile pictures and latest photos appear elsewhere too? If so, they are the easiest link to find.
  6. Do your latest posts contain details of your life? Reread ten of them through the eyes of someone who knows you.

The full sequence for separating identities again, from prevention to recovery, is in the guide on how to manage multiple online identities.

If you find a suspicious sign

Stay calm: in most cases it is a point in common left there for convenience, and changing it is enough. If, however, the sign involves someone using your name under the pseudonym, or a profile pretending to be you, it is worth:

  • taking screenshots, showing the date and the page address;
  • reporting the content or profile with the platform’s tools;
  • asking whoever wrote your name to remove it, if it is someone you know;
  • if there are threats, blackmail or attempts at fraud, contacting the police.

Over the following days keep an eye on two things: new comments or messages using your name on the separate identity, and account recovery requests you did not make. If nothing appears, it is very likely that the link has stayed among a few people. If you feel in danger, for example because someone close to you is monitoring or threatening you, the first step is to talk to a specialist service: in England, GOV.UK lists Refuge’s National Domestic Abuse Helpline, free and open 24 hours a day.

The signs that stronger anonymity is giving way, for those who need it, are also gathered in the post on the signs your anonymity is slipping.

What is not an indicator

Some situations look suspicious but are usually normal:

  • the separate identity is suggested to strangers: services also suggest profiles based on shared interests or area;
  • someone you know follows the separate identity without knowing it is yours: if they like the same topics, it can happen by chance;
  • someone says the pseudonym “writes like you”: similarities in style are common and, on their own, only give an impression;
  • lots of followers from your own city: if you write about your city, that is normal;
  • a pseudonym like yours used by others: invented names repeat more than you might think;
  • an email from the service addressed to the pseudonym in the dedicated inbox: that is exactly where it should arrive; the sign is when it lands in your personal inbox.

The rule for telling the difference is always the same: a link is a sign when it goes through a detail that only you and your named identity have in common. If in doubt, the cautious choice costs nothing: check recovery, number and connected apps.

How often to check

WhenWhat to check
Every time one identity suggests someone from the otherNumber, contacts and connected apps
When you open a new account for a separate identityAddress, recovery, password and browser
When you change phone, number or email addressEach identity’s recovery details
Once a yearThe settings of every account and any shared photos

Two important caveats

First caveat: no sign is conclusive. A suggestion can come from a shared interest, and a well-separated identity can be recognised by someone who knows you very well. The most reliable sign is still the simplest: a detail that only your identities have in common, such as the recovery address or the number.

Second caveat: menus change. Option names and paths in the settings vary between services, apps and versions. If you cannot find an option, search the service’s official help for words such as “account recovery”, “connected apps”, “active sessions” or “contact syncing”.

How this connects to the Cyber Welfare Framework

PillarHow this content contributes
AwarenessRecognising that a suggestion, a comment or a notification in the wrong inbox are signs, even when they look harmless
SkillsKnowing how to read each account’s recovery, connected apps, active sessions and contact settings
Secure BehaviourStopping at a link you did not choose, finding the point in common and calmly changing it

Reference level: FL2 — Beginner. This is the level where you start noticing when your identities cross over and asking why. To see where you stand on your other digital habits, you can take the digital resilience self-assessment.

Conclusion

The most common sign is also the simplest: a separate identity is suggested to someone who knows you. Almost always it is a number or recovery left in common. Sometimes it is a detail in your posts or photos. Either way the answer is the same: find the point in common, change it and decide what to do with the people who already know.

Noticing is the first step. The second is making sure your identities cross over only where you decided.

Related resources

Short reads from the Resources section, for anyone who wants to focus on a single aspect:

Related content

Start with the first step: the Cyber Welfare Programme guides you free of charge, one recommendation at a time.