John is 68, retired for three years, and lives with his wife on the outskirts of Milan. One Tuesday evening he realises that in a single week his phone has rung six times for reasons that do not interest him: energy offers, a recorded message about a refund “on hold”, a magazine subscription. The last call is different. A very polite woman says she is calling for his bank, addresses him by name and asks him to “confirm your date of birth, just for security”.
John has never given his number to any of these people. Or so he thinks. Then he thinks again: the supermarket loyalty card, the washing machine warranty, a furniture shop’s prize draw, the bowls club profile. Where has his number ended up, and who said yes on his behalf?
This recommendation, R36 of the Cyber Welfare Framework, suggests two simple habits: share your phone number only where needed, and confirm nothing to anyone who calls out of the blue. It does not ask you to hide your number from everyone. It asks you to choose where it goes from now on, and to have a sentence ready for anyone who asks you to “verify” something.
What this recommendation says
Recommendation R36 states that your phone number should go only to people and services that need to reach you, and that nothing is ever confirmed on an unexpected call.
Three terms to clear up straight away:
- personal data is information that identifies a person or lets them be identified, even indirectly: the UK Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) explains that someone is identifiable if they can be distinguished from others, and a phone number does just that;
- an optional field is a box on a form that you can leave empty without losing the service: the phone number is often one of them, even when it does not look like it;
- vishing (from “voice” and “phishing”) is the scam that uses the phone to get you to hand over details, codes or money, usually by pretending to be someone you trust.
In practice, the recommendation comes down to two actions, to combine as you see fit:
- choose where your number goes: give it to whoever needs to call or text you (the courier, the engineer coming to your home), use it for account security if you find that helpful, leave it out of optional fields and remove it from the public part of your profiles;
- confirm nothing to a caller: if an unexpected call asks you to verify a detail or read out a code, end the call calmly and call back yourself, on the official number you find on your own, on the organisation’s website, your contract or the back of your card.
What it is not. It is not a call never to give out your number. Using it for two-factor authentication or to recover an account can be a sensible choice, and the recommendation on protecting accounts with a second factor explains when, and what the alternatives are. It does not go into detail on fake messages from your bank, which are the subject of the recommendation to be wary of emails pretending to be your bank, nor on the overall visibility of your profiles, covered by the recommendation on checking who can see your profile. And it does not promise to end unwanted calls: national opt-out registers reduce calls from organisations that follow the rules, but they do not stop scams.
Where it applies. To your mobile and your landline, to paper and online forms, to apps, profiles and messaging, and to incoming calls, even from a number that looks familiar.
Why it matters
A phone number is like the key to a letterbox you cannot move: the more copies you hand out, the more people can drop something inside.
A number travels along two routes. The first is the forms you filled in yourself: a delivery, a warranty, a marketing box left ticked years ago. The second is the lists you never saw: sites that publish numbers, lists passed between companies, data breaches that exposed customers’ contact details. The UK’s National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC) puts it plainly: if the information stolen in a breach includes phone numbers, you might receive a suspicious call.
There is also a less visible side. Many services now use your number as an identifier, a label that ties together accounts, profiles and messaging apps. The US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) explains that on sites that sell information about people, starting from just a name or a phone number, someone can buy a report with addresses and relatives.
Finally, a phone call leaves no time to check. The caller already knows a little about you, perhaps your name and your bank, and asks you to confirm the rest: a date of birth, a code that has just arrived by text. Every detail you confirm adds to what they know. The UK government’s Stop! Think Fraud campaign lists exactly this among the signs of phone fraud: a caller asking you to share a one-time passcode or PIN, codes that can authorise a payment in your name.
The concrete consequences show up on four fronts:
- more calls and messages you did not ask for, some of them scams;
- a thread that links your data: your number connects profiles and accounts that would otherwise stay separate;
- details confirmed to people who should not have them: every answer to an unexpected call makes the next one more convincing;
- more exposed accounts: if your number receives sign-in codes, anyone who controls it, or gets you to read a code, can get in.
| Benefit of sharing your number only where needed | Why it counts |
|---|---|
| Fewer places where your number is stored | Fewer forms, lists and directories it can leak from |
| Fewer sales calls | Anyone without your number, or your consent, cannot call you to sell |
| Profiles that are harder to link | Your number does not act as a bridge between accounts |
| No details handed to a friendly voice | The caller is left with what they already knew, and nothing more |
A concrete example
Back to John, on that Tuesday evening.
He answers the woman “from the bank” with the sentence his son suggested months ago: “I don’t confirm anything on the phone, I’ll call the bank myself.” She insists, politely; John thanks her and hangs up. Then he turns his bank card over and calls the number on the back. The bank confirms that nobody has been trying to reach him.
The next day, with his daughter, he writes down on a sheet of paper the places where he remembers giving his number. There are eighteen. For each one they ask: did it really need to call me? The boiler engineer, yes; the furniture shop’s prize draw and the magazine, no.
They search for the number in quotation marks: it appears in an old advert and on a directory site, next to his home address. John asks both to remove it. He takes the number off the bowls club’s public profile, leaving it visible to members only. He registers his mobile and landline with the national opt-out register, knowing that it reduces sales calls, not scam calls. Finally he writes to two companies to say he no longer wants offers.
Half an hour in all. The calls do not disappear, but over the following weeks they thin out, and the next friendly voice does not catch him off guard.
When to apply it
There are moments when the rule makes an obvious difference.
- When a form asks for your number. Check whether the field is required, and ask yourself whether the service really needs to call or text you. If not, leave it empty.
- When there is a marketing box. Leave it empty, or untick it if it is already ticked, if you do not want offers.
- When you open or update a public profile. A number visible to everyone is a choice, not an obligation.
- When an unexpected call asks you to confirm something. Details, codes, “security checks”: you confirm nothing and call back yourself.
- When a code arrives that you did not request. Someone is trying to use your number to get into an account: the code is not for anyone else.
How to apply it
You do not need to change your number or install anything.
- List the places where your number lives. Shops, cards, warranties, deliveries, profiles, apps, clubs: mark the ones that can send you offers.
- Ask, for each one, whether it is really needed. Anyone who needs to reach you for a concrete reason keeps the number. The others do not.
- Remove your number where it is not needed. Delete it from profiles that allow it, leave optional fields empty, and tell companies to stop contacting you for marketing: under Article 21 of the GDPR and the UK GDPR, you have the right to object to direct marketing, and from then on your data can no longer be used for that purpose.
- Take your number off the public part of your profiles. Where it stays, choose who can see it, contacts only or nobody, and check whether the service lets others find you by your number.
- Search for your number. Type it in quotation marks into a search engine, in the format you usually use. If it appears on a site you do not know, look for the page to request removal.
- Use your country’s opt-out register. Ofcom, the UK communications regulator, explains that registering tells legitimate marketers you do not want sales calls, and that it will not block scam calls. Most countries have a similar free service.
- Prepare your sentence for callers. For example: “I don’t confirm anything on an incoming call. I’ll call you back on the official number.” Use it even when the voice is kind and already knows your name.
The steps in order of priority, with what to do if you have already confirmed something, are in the guide on how to reduce unwanted calls. Phone and provider filters and opt-out registers, with their strengths and limits, are described in the post on call filtering and do-not-call registers.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Thinking your number is “out there anyway”. You cannot recall every copy, but you can decide where it goes from today and withdraw old consents.
- Trusting the number on the screen. Ofcom reminds us that scammers can fake the number that appears: this is number spoofing. A familiar number does not tell you who is really on the line.
- Confirming “just one” detail. A date of birth seems harmless, but it makes the next call more convincing, or helps get past another service’s checks.
- Calling back the number the caller gives you. If you want to check, use a number you find yourself, through a channel you know.
- Believing the register stops everything. It reduces calls from those who follow the rules; for scammers, you need your own rule.
- Taking your number off your accounts out of fear. A code by text is better than no protection; if you want to depend less on your number, there are methods that do not go through the phone.
How this connects to the Cyber Welfare Framework
R36 brings privacy into an everyday gesture: writing, or not writing, your number on a form, and answering, or not answering, a question on the phone. It takes the habit of checking rather than acting, the same one that applies to fake messages from your bank, and extends it to everything your number ties together.
| Pillar | How this contributes |
|---|---|
| Skills | Knowing how to search for your own number, take it off profiles, request removal, object to marketing and register with an opt-out service |
| Awareness | Understanding that your number is personal data that travels through forms, directories and breaches, and that it links accounts and profiles |
| Secure Behaviour | Sharing your number only where needed, leaving optional fields empty and confirming nothing on an unexpected call |
Digital maturity levels.
- FL1 — Basic. You give your number whenever you are asked and answer callers’ questions, because it feels like the polite thing to do. It is the most common starting point, not a fault.
- FL2 — Beginner. You leave optional fields empty, you have your sentence ready and, when asked to confirm something, you hang up and call back yourself.
- FL3 — Autonomous. You have listed where your number lives, searched for it, objected to marketing you do not want and chosen your phone’s filters with care.
- FL4 — Skilled. You know which accounts depend on your number, you have protected your line with your provider and you use sign-in methods that do not rely on texts alone.
- FL5 — Expert-Guide. You help parents, friends or colleagues trace their own number and prepare their sentence, calmly and without making anyone feel foolish.
R36 is the key step from FL1 to FL2, and it remains an active habit at every level after that.
How to check you are applying it properly
Three questions, to answer honestly.
- Could I say where I have given my number in the past year, and why?
- Is my number visible to everyone on any profile or advert?
- What would I say, today, to a friendly voice asking me to confirm a code?
Quick checklist
- ☐ I have listed the places where my number lives
- ☐ I leave optional fields and marketing boxes empty
- ☐ My number is not public on my profiles
- ☐ I have searched for my number and requested removal where needed
- ☐ I have registered my numbers with my country’s opt-out register
- ☐ I have written down my sentence for callers who ask me to confirm
If a box stays empty, you already have your next step. For a more structured measure of your level, take the digital resilience self-assessment.
In short
Your phone number is personal data that identifies you and reaches you; it travels through forms, directories and breaches, and it ties together many of your accounts.
You cannot recall every copy, but you can choose where it goes from now on: to those who need to reach you, and nowhere else. And to anyone who calls out of the blue asking you to confirm something, you give nothing: you hang up and call back yourself, on a number you have found on your own.
Who can reach you is, in the end, your decision.
Something to think about. Think of the last place you wrote down your phone number. Did it really need it?
Explore this recommendation
This recommendation is the pivot of a content unit. Each post looks at a different aspect.
- Risks of an exposed phone number — what gets hit, in terms of the confidentiality, integrity and availability of your data and your accounts
- What a widely shared phone number can lead to — the concrete effects on the operational, financial, legal, reputational and personal levels
- How to reduce unwanted calls — the mitigations, from optional fields to searching for your number, through to recovery after one confirmation too many
- Signs your phone number is out there — the indicators to check and what they mean
- Call filtering and do-not-call registers — registers, provider and phone filters, filtering apps and number visibility, with their strengths and limits
- Vishing phone scams — the ways a number is used to deceive, from calls with a faked number to SIM swaps
Related resources
Short reads from the Resources section, for anyone who wants to focus on a single aspect:
- Spam Calls: How Your Number Spreads and How to Cut Them
- Re-identification: Why a Few Details Can Identify You
- How to Prevent Doxxing: Spot the Signs, Reduce Your Exposure
- Online Banking Security: A Separate Address for the Bank
Start with the first step: the Cyber Welfare Programme guides you free of charge, one recommendation at a time.




