CYBER WELFARE

Protect your Digital Privacy

Keeping separate identities separate: different accounts, details and habits for each

Lucy has two young children, a husband who only cooks on Sundays and, for three years now, a family recipe blog she signs as “Basil”. None of her friends knows it is her. There is nothing to hide: she just likes the recipes to speak for themselves, without her face next to them.

One evening the colleague she shares a desk with messages her: “The social network is suggesting someone called Basil as a person I might know. Their cakes look just like yours!”. Lucy laughs, but then she wonders: how did the network put her and Basil together? She had set up the blog’s profile with her own phone number, the one her colleague has in her contacts. The pseudonym hid her name, but not her number.

This recommendation, R44 of the Cyber Welfare Framework, invites you to do what Lucy did that evening: keep separate online identities apart when you want them apart, by finding what they have in common and giving each one its own accounts, details and habits. It does not ask you to hide, but to decide where the line runs between one part of your life and another.

What this recommendation says

Recommendation R44 states that an identity you want to keep separate from your name stays separate only if it has nothing in common with the others.

Three terms to clear up first:

  • an online identity is the way you present yourself in a given space: the profile with your name, a blog’s pseudonym, a club’s account, a nickname on a forum;
  • a pseudonym is a name you choose instead of your legal one, as the glossary entry on what a pseudonym is explains; a pseudonym is not anonymity: it hides your name, but an identity with a pseudonym can still be linked back to you;
  • a point in common is any detail two identities share: an email address, a recovery number, a password, a photo, a contact, a time of day, a device, a way of writing.

In practice, the recommendation comes down to three steps:

  • take stock of the points in common between the separate identity and the one with your name;
  • give each identity its own set: its own account and address, its own recovery details, a unique password, a separate browser profile, photos and contacts that do not lead back to the other;
  • decide what to do when the identities cross over: separate them again, or accept the link.

What it is not. It is not an invitation to deceive anyone, or to create fake profiles to harm others: a separate identity protects one part of your life, it does not pretend to be someone else. It is not a guide to strong anonymity: for that there is the recommendation on when to use Tor Browser. Nor does it tell you how much separation you need: that is the starting question of the recommendation on deciding how much anonymity you need. Platform rules and the law apply to every identity too: this recommendation does not explain how to get round checks or bans. Finally, account security stays the same: a unique password for every account and protecting accounts with a second factor apply to every identity.

Where it applies. To anyone who writes under a pseudonym, has a profile for a hobby, runs a club’s account or keeps work and private life apart. If you face a serious, targeted risk, for example because of your work or because someone close to you is monitoring you, this recommendation is not enough: the first step is to contact a specialist organisation. In England, GOV.UK lists Refuge’s National Domestic Abuse Helpline, free and open 24 hours a day.

Why it matters

Two separate identities are like two houses with different front doors. But if they share the same letterbox and the same bicycle in the yard, it does not take much to work out that the same person lives in both.

The mechanism is this. A separate identity is linked back to you not by its name, but by the details it shares with the others. Some are visible to everyone, such as a photo or a favourite phrase. Others only the service sees: the sign-up email, the recovery number, the device you sign in from. The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), a US digital rights organisation, says so in its guide to social networks: for a lot of us it is critical to keep different account identities separate, and if you want to hide your identity it helps to use a separate email address, avoid giving your phone number and choose an image you do not use anywhere else. It adds that photos, in particular, can sneakily link accounts you intend to keep separate.

Then there is the human side. Friends can recognise you without meaning to, write your name under a post, follow both profiles. And services, to suggest “people you may know”, can use clues such as mutual contacts and, depending on the service, address books that users upload: exactly how this works is not public, but the result is what Lucy saw.

Your way of writing is a point in common too. Style analysis, known as stylometry, compares habits such as your most frequent words and punctuation: it gives probabilities, not proof, and on its own it is a weak link, which grows stronger when it adds up with the others.

The consequences show up on four fronts:

  • privacy: a part of your life you wanted to keep to yourself becomes readable by people who know the other;
  • control: you no longer decide who knows what;
  • dependence: if the identities share a recovery address or number, a problem on one spreads to the other;
  • freedom: knowing someone could link you makes you write less freely.
Benefit of keeping identities separateWhy it matters
You decide where the line runsPeople who know one identity do not stumble on the other
No awkward suggestionsWithout a shared number and contacts, services have fewer clues to suggest you
A problem stays where it isA lost or hacked account does not drag the other one down with it
More freedom of expressionYou write in your own voice, without thinking about who might recognise you
A link is a choiceIf one day you want to reveal who you are, you do it, when you want

A concrete example

Back to Lucy, on the evening of her colleague’s message.

She takes a sheet of paper and splits it into two columns: “me” and “Basil”. Then she writes down what they have in common. The blog’s account on the social network is registered with her phone number. Recovery goes through her personal email. The password is the same as her personal profile’s, with a different number at the end. The photos are taken in her kitchen, with the same green tiles that appear in the photos of the children’s birthdays on her personal profile. The laptop’s browser is signed in to both accounts, and on a recipe site she comments via “Sign in with…” her personal profile. Her habits: she posts on the blog at half past nine, when the children are asleep, and that same evening often puts a photo of the cake on her personal profile too. And she ends every recipe with “happy snacking!”, the same phrase she writes in the parents’ group chat.

Lucy does not want to change how she writes. She works on the links that weigh most. She creates an email address just for Basil, with its own recovery, and puts it in place of the phone number. She sets a new password from her password manager and turns on two-step verification with an app. She opens a browser profile just for the blog. She removes from her personal profile the cake photos also on the blog and, from then on, photographs her recipes on a wooden chopping board. On the recipe site she signs up again with Basil’s email.

To her colleague she tells the truth: “Yes, it’s me. Could you keep it to yourself?”. Lucy chose to accept that link, with a person she trusts, and to separate everything else.

When to apply it

There are moments when the rule makes an obvious difference.

  • When you open a new identity. A dedicated set takes a few minutes at the start, much longer later.
  • When a service offers to “find your friends”. Uploading your contacts from a separate identity links it to the people who know you by name.
  • When one identity suggests someone you know from the other. It is the sign that a point in common already exists.
  • When you change phone, email address or number. Update recovery details identity by identity, without letting them all converge on one address.

How to apply it

You need no special tools. Just a short sequence, repeated for each identity.

  1. Write down your identities. For each one, ask yourself who should know it is yours, and who should not.
  2. Take stock of the points in common. Sign-up and recovery email, phone number, password, profile picture, photos, contacts and people you follow, times of day, devices and browser, “Sign in with…”, recurring phrases.
  3. Give the identity its own address. An email address just for it, with recovery that is not your personal email. An address with an addition to your name, such as “name+blog”, is not enough: it shows the main address.
  4. Protect the account like the others. A unique password, stored in your password manager, and two-step verification. If the service asks for a phone number, consider whether you really need to give it or can use another method, as the recommendation on sharing your phone number only where it is needed explains.
  5. Separate your browser. Use a dedicated browser profile, with its own cookies and sign-ins, and do not use “Sign in with…” your personal profile: the recommendation on limiting social login explains why. A browser that limits tracking reduces the links you cannot see.
  6. Choose its own photos and contacts. A profile picture you do not use elsewhere, photos without faces or recognisable details and without location (see the recommendation on turning off photo geotagging), no uploaded address book. Decide who follows the identity and who sees it, as the recommendations on checking who can see your profile and connecting only with people you know suggest.
  7. Reread before you post. Remove life details that lead to you, such as your neighbourhood or your children’s school: they matter more than style.
  8. When identities cross over, decide. Separate them again, by changing the point in common, or accept the link with the people who already know. Both are legitimate choices.

The full sequence, from prevention to recovery, is in the guide on how to manage multiple online identities. The tools that help, with their strengths and limits, are described in the post on digital compartmentalisation.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Thinking a different name is enough. The recovery email and the phone number link identities even when nobody can see them.
  • Using the same password “with a small tweak”. If one is exposed, the other is easy to guess, and the two identities are revealed as yours.
  • Posting the same photo on both profiles. It is the quickest link to find, even by chance.
  • Keeping everything in one browser. Shared cookies and sign-ins show services both identities together.
  • Thinking you must separate everything for ever. You do not: separation comes in degrees. A trusted person who knows both identities is not a mistake.

How this connects to the Cyber Welfare Framework

R44 brings anonymity into everyday life: not one more tool, but a tidy way of keeping the parts of your online life apart, handing back to you the decision on who knows what.

PillarHow this contributes
SkillsKnowing how to take stock of the points in common and create a dedicated set for each identity: address, recovery, password, browser profile
AwarenessUnderstanding that a pseudonym hides your name but not the details you share, and that links add up
Secure BehaviourKeeping accounts, details and habits distinct over time, and calmly deciding what to do when identities cross over

Digital maturity levels.

  • FL1 — Basic. You use several identities, but with the same email address, the same number and the same browser. It is the most common starting point, not a fault.
  • FL2 — Beginner. You know a pseudonym can be linked back to you and you have done a first stocktake of the points in common.
  • FL3 — Autonomous. Each identity has its own address, its own recovery, a unique password and a browser profile; you check photos and contacts before you post.
  • FL4 — Skilled. You recognise the signs of a link, you can separate two identities that have crossed over and you also manage a group account with other people.
  • FL5 — Expert-Guide. You help family, friends or colleagues work out how much separation they really need, without alarm and without judging their choices.

R44 is the key step from FL2 to FL3, and it remains an active habit at every level after that.

How to check you are applying it properly

Three questions, to be answered honestly.

  • If someone knew only my separate identity, which detail would lead them to my name fastest?
  • Do my identities share an email address, a recovery number or a password?
  • When did I last reread a post from my separate identity looking for details of my life?

Quick checklist

  • ☐ I have written down my identities and, for each one, who should know it is mine
  • ☐ Each separate identity has its own email address and recovery
  • ☐ Each account has a unique password and two-step verification
  • ☐ I use a different browser profile for the separate identity, without “Sign in with…” my personal profile
  • ☐ The profile picture and posted photos do not appear anywhere else
  • ☐ I have not uploaded my contacts from the separate identity

If a box stays empty, you already have your next step. For a more structured measure of your level, take the digital resilience self-assessment.

In short

A separate identity is linked back to you not by its name, but by what it shares with the others: the recovery email, the number, the password, a photo, a contact, a habit. Each point is small; together they can be enough.

The answer is a stocktake and a dedicated set: address, recovery, password, browser profile, photos and contacts of its own. And, when identities cross over, a calm choice: separate them again or accept the link.

Having several identities is normal and legitimate. Where the line runs between them is your decision.

Something to think about. If someone who knows you well read your separate identity, which detail would they recognise you by first?

Explore this recommendation

This recommendation is the pivot of a content unit. Each post looks at a different aspect.

Related resources

Short reads from the Resources section, for anyone who wants to focus on a single aspect:

Start with the first step: the Cyber Welfare Programme guides you free of charge, one recommendation at a time.