CYBER WELFARE

Protect your Digital Privacy

Choosing your search engine knowingly: what it keeps and what it links to you

Mark is 22, studying at university while he works. He has just bought a new phone. When he switches it on for the first time, somewhere between the language, the Wi-Fi and the fingerprint, a screen appears with a list of search engines to choose from. In a hurry, he taps the first name he recognises. On his laptop, he never chose a search engine at all: it was already there the first time he opened the browser, and there it stayed.

A few weeks later Mark is looking for a flat and, without having told anyone yet, a new job in another city. One evening he scrolls through his searches from the last few days: rents in a particular neighbourhood, average salaries for a profession, train times, how to write a resignation letter. Nothing to be ashamed of. Put in a row, though, they tell the story of a plan he has not yet shared with his family. Who has he handed all these questions to, and who decided that?

This recommendation, R37 of the Cyber Welfare Framework, invites you to choose your search engine using criteria of your own, instead of keeping the one that came with your device. It does not say which one is best. It offers three questions for reading a search engine’s privacy promise, a one-week trial to see how you get on, and a final step: setting the one you have chosen as your default. Staying where you are is a valid choice too, as long as you make it knowing what it involves.

What this recommendation says

Recommendation R37 states that the search engine you use every day should be your own choice, made knowing what it keeps of your searches and what it links to you.

Four terms to clear up straight away:

  • your default search engine is the one your browser or phone uses when you type a question into the address bar or the search box;
  • your search history is the list of questions you have asked, which some services keep, sometimes together with the result you tapped;
  • your IP address is the number that identifies your internet connection while you are online, and that every site can see;
  • linking a search to you means associating it with something that identifies you: an account, a device, an IP address, or a cookie, a small file a site stores in your browser to recognise you.

In practice, the recommendation comes down to three actions:

  • read the privacy promise of two search engines, with three questions: what does it keep, what does it link to you, and what limits does it commit to;
  • try one for a week, in your everyday searching;
  • set the one you choose as your default, in your browser and on your phone, or keep the one you have and review its history settings.

What it is not. It is not a ranking, and it does not promise anonymity. A privacy-minded search engine decides what happens to your questions, but it does not hide your connection from your network provider or from the sites you visit: for that there is the recommendation on using a VPN for sensitive traffic, and there is the topic of a browser that limits tracking by default. Nor does it cover the history your accounts keep in general, the subject of the recommendation on reviewing what your accounts keep, or the questions you ask an artificial intelligence assistant, covered by the recommendation on checking your AI assistant’s data settings.

Where it applies. To every place where you type a question: the browser on your computer, the one on your phone, the search box on your phone’s home screen, the family tablet. It matters most for the searches you make every day without thinking.

Why it matters

Searches are some of the most candid things you write online. You type them quickly, often before you have talked to anyone about what is on your mind: a move, a present, a change of job, a doubt about a tenancy agreement. One by one they say little. Taken together, over time, they sketch your interests, plans and habits.

Every search engine has to see your question in order to answer it: that does not change. What changes is what happens next. Some services say they do not keep your IP address and do not associate searches with the person who made them. Others save them to your account, use them to choose adverts and keep them until you delete them. In between there are many shades.

European data protection authorities have been looking at this for a long time. In Opinion 1/2008 on search engines, adopted on 4 April 2008, the Article 29 Working Party (the body that brought together Europe’s data protection authorities before the European Data Protection Board) said that search engines must justify keeping personal data for longer than, in principle, six months, and that data no longer needed should be deleted or anonymised in a genuinely effective way. The European Commission, for its part, lists an IP address and a cookie ID among its examples of personal data.

The practical effects show up in four areas:

  • an archive that talks about you: searches kept and linked to your name tell more than you remember yourself;
  • a profile that decides what you see: adverts and suggestions chosen on the basis of what you searched for weeks ago;
  • more damage if someone gets into your account: whoever takes it over finds years of questions neatly in order;
  • a choice you never made: default settings decide for you who receives your questions.
Benefit of choosing your search engineWhy it matters
You know who receives your questionsThe decision comes back to you, not to the device
Fewer searches linked to your nameA smaller profile, and less to lose if an account is breached
Adverts based on the search, not on youYou see adverts about what you are asking now, not about your past
Promises you can checkA clear, dated rule is worth more than a general reassurance
A choice you can reverseChanging your default takes a minute, and you can go back

A concrete example

Back to Mark, on a Sunday afternoon.

He picks two search engines he has heard about and opens each one’s privacy page. For each, he asks three questions. What does it keep? The first says it does not save search history; the second says it makes the IP address anonymous after a few days. What does it link to me? The first writes that it does not associate searches with the user or the IP address; the second explains that it shares searches with a partner that supplies the results. What limits does it commit to? Here Mark notices the difference between a sentence like “we care about your privacy” and one like “we do not store IP addresses”: the second is a rule that can be checked. He also notices the date at the bottom of the page, because rules change.

He sets the first as the default on his laptop and leaves his phone as it is, so he can compare. For a week he searches as usual: addresses, recipes, job information, prices. Each time he goes back to his old search engine to find something, he jots it down in a note. By the end of the week there are four notes, almost all for shops and opening hours near home, because the new search engine uses a rougher location.

Mark decides to keep it, on his laptop and then on his phone too, and to use the old one, when he needs it, for “near me” searches. Twenty minutes of reading and a week’s trial. He now knows who receives his questions, and why he chose it.

When to apply it

There are moments when the choice makes an obvious difference.

  • When you set up a new phone, tablet or computer. This is when the default is decided, often with a hurried tap. In some places, such as the European Union, you may also be offered a choice screen.
  • When you install or reinstall a browser. The default search engine comes with the browser: it is a chance to ask yourself whether it is the one you want.
  • When a search engine changes its privacy policy. If you get a notice about a policy change, go back to the three questions.
  • Once a year, alongside your account check. It is the right moment to review the history your search engine keeps, if it keeps one.

How to apply it

You need no knowledge of every browser’s menus. A short sequence is enough.

  1. Check which search engine you use today. Open your browser’s settings and look for a section called “Search”, “Search engine” or “Address bar”. Do the same on your phone and tablet: the search engine is often different from one device to the next.
  2. Pick two search engines to compare. You can include the one you already use. They do not need to be the “right” ones: what matters is reading them.
  3. Read their privacy pages with three questions. What does it keep? (does it store searches, and for how long?) What does it link to you? (an account, a device, your IP address?) What limits does it commit to? Look for specific sentences and check the date of the page.
  4. Prefer “cannot” to “will not”. A service that explains it cannot see certain data, because it does not collect or keep it, offers a firmer guarantee than one that promises not to look. The Electronic Frontier Foundation, a digital rights organisation, suggests the same test for judging any tool.
  5. Try your chosen search engine for a week. Set it as the default on one device and note each time you go back to the old one, and why.
  6. Decide, and set the default everywhere. Computer browser, phone browser, phone search box, tablet. If you stay with your usual search engine, open its history settings and decide whether to keep the history, pause it or have it deleted automatically after a period.

The steps in detail, device by device, including what to do if your default changes without your deciding, are in the guide on how to change your default search engine. The differences between search engines with their own index, intermediary search engines and metasearch engines are explained in the post on types of search engines.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Thinking private browsing hides your searches from the search engine. It clears the history on your device when the session ends. The US Federal Trade Commission points out that it does not stop websites from seeing what you do.
  • Believing a privacy-minded search engine makes you anonymous. It protects what happens to your questions, not your connection: your network provider and the sites you open can still see you.
  • Trusting general reassurances. “Your privacy matters to us” tells you nothing you can check. A specific, dated rule tells you a great deal more.
  • Changing search engine on one device only. Your phone, tablet and laptop have separate settings: a choice made on one does not apply to the others.
  • Thinking that staying with your usual search engine is a mistake. It is not, if you chose it knowing what it keeps and have set up its history the way you want.

How this connects to the Cyber Welfare Framework

R37 turns an inherited setting into a choice you have tested. It sits alongside the recommendation to turn off Bluetooth and location when you are not using them: the location that travels with your “near me” searches is also something you can decide to share less of.

PillarHow this contributes
SkillsKnowing how to find your default search engine, read a privacy page with three questions, change the default and change it back
AwarenessUnderstanding that searches linked to you can describe your interests and plans, and that search engines follow different rules
Secure BehaviourChoosing your default with clear criteria, trying it for a week and rereading privacy policies once a year

Digital maturity levels.

  • FL1 — Basic. You use the search engine that came with your device, without knowing what it keeps. It is the most common starting point, not a fault.
  • FL2 — Beginner. You have read the privacy promise of two search engines with the three questions and chosen your default, even if it is the one you had before.
  • FL3 — Autonomous. You have the same chosen default on all your devices, you manage your search history and you reread privacy policies when they change.
  • FL4 — Skilled. You can tell apart search engines with their own index, intermediaries and metasearch engines, and you use different search engines for different purposes, on purpose.
  • FL5 — Expert-Guide. You help family, colleagues or students make the same choice, without imposing yours and without judging theirs.

R37 is the key step at the FL2 — Beginner level, and it remains a useful habit at every level after that.

How to check you are applying it properly

Three questions, to be answered honestly.

  • Do I know which search engine I use on my phone, my computer and my tablet?
  • Could I say what it keeps of my searches, and whether it links them to me?
  • Did I choose it, or did it come with the device?

Quick checklist

  • ☐ I have checked the default search engine on all my devices
  • ☐ I have read the privacy page of at least two search engines, with the three questions
  • ☐ I have looked at the date of both privacy policies
  • ☐ I have tried the search engine that convinced me most for a week
  • ☐ I have set the default I chose, everywhere
  • ☐ If I am staying with my usual search engine, I have set up its history settings

If a box stays empty, you already have your next step. For a more structured measure of your level, take the digital resilience self-assessment.

In short

Your default search engine is almost always a choice made by someone else. Your searches say a lot about you, and search engines differ in what they keep, for how long, and whether they link your questions to your account or your connection.

The answer is simple: read the privacy promise of two search engines with three questions, prefer “cannot” to “will not”, try one for a week and set the one you choose everywhere.

Your search engine is not a fixture of your device. It is a choice, and you can make it again whenever you like.

Something to think about. Of the searches you made this week, which one would you least like to see linked to your name?

Explore this recommendation

This recommendation is the pivot of a content unit. Each post looks at a different aspect.

Related resources

Short reads from the Resources section, for anyone who wants to focus on a single aspect:

Start with the first step: the Cyber Welfare Programme guides you free of charge, one recommendation at a time.